IAS Materials

A Free Way to Become an IAS

  • Home
  • Prelims
  • Mains
  • Optionals
  • Coaching Materials
  • E-Books
  • Test Series
  • Current Affairs
  • Advertise With US

Join other Aspirants

Enter your Mail ID and get Access for Everything !

You are here: Home / Fine Editorials / The gaps in the Mental Healthcare Act

The gaps in the Mental Healthcare Act

December 24, 2017 By Swamy Vivekananda Leave a Comment

The Mental Healthcare Act suffers from several gaps that the original Bill proposed by UPA-II had covered

The original Mental Healthcare Bill clearly outlined how and when one could create an advance directive.

Here Each and Every PDF is provided for Free and should be used for Education purposes only. Please utilize them wisely and don't make them Commercial. We request you to respect our Hard Work.

Join Our Telegram Channel

We gather all these tests and Materials with intense struggle, so if anyone subscribed to any test series or material please forward us at [email protected], We remove all the tracing items from the pdf and We Respect Your Privacy.

If you are fresh UPSC Aspirant, We recommend you to know about UPSC Prelims and UPSC Mains and also UPSC Optionals for better Understanding. Here, All our Advertisements are Decent ads [we don't compromise in the Quality] and if anyone have any problem with website or advertisements please contact me [email protected]

Short Notes IAS Yearly Current Affairs Revision

The original Mental Healthcare Bill clearly outlined how and when one could create an advance directive. Photo: iStockphoto

 

The need for legislation which secures the rights of people with mental illness is a necessity for a nation like India. Instances such as the 2001 Erwadi mental home fire, in which chained patients were charred to death, are a reminder of our apathy towards the mentally disabled. The neglect of mental health is evident from a World Health Organization report which estimated that 50 million Indians suffered from depression.

The enactment of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017 by the current government is an attempt to protect the rights of the mentally ill and enable citizens to decide on the method of treatment in case of mental illness, lest they are mistreated or neglected.

India ratified the UN Convention on Rights of Persons with Disabilities in October 2007. The United Progressive Alliance government (UPA-II) initially introduced the Mental Health Care Bill in August 2013 to replace the Mental Health Act, 1987 to bring the law in consonance with the obligations of the UN convention. The Bill lapsed due to the dissolution of the Lok Sabha.

The 16th Lok Sabha led by the National Democratic Alliance (NDA) reintroduced the Bill in August 2016 with 134 amendments. The modifications led to a complete overhaul of the intent, structure and provisions of the original Bill, and the spirit of the UN convention was missing. The overhaul of UPA-II’s Bill creates serious doubts about whether the objectives would be met.

During the discussion on the reintroduced Bill in March 2017 in the Lok Sabha, I proposed four crucial amendments relating to changes in definitions, and to ensure clarity and strengthen the provisions of the Bill. The reintroduced Bill was passed by both Houses; it has received Presidential assent and is in force as the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017.

The draft rules and regulations to be framed under the Mental Healthcare Act were prepared and put out for public scrutiny. The requirement of garnering comments from stakeholders and experts on the proposed rules is mandated by law but it is not binding upon the ministry to adopt and implement them.

Various mental health experts and non-governmental organizations initiated public debates and raised the lacunae in the draft rules and regulations with the ministry of health and family welfare. I will discuss some key issues that should be considered by the ministry in order to ensure that such legislation creates an ecosystem for proper treatment of the mentally disabled.

First, the Act recognizes mental illness as a clinical issue which can only be treated by medicines and clinical procedures.

The important issue of prevention and promotion of mental well-being has been neglected. Research shows that in cases of mental illness, medical interventions occur at an advanced stage. Illness is also a result of one’s social setting and preliminary treatment can be provided by qualified psychotherapists, counsellors and psychoanalysts.

This concern was flagged in the Lok Sabha and the House urged the minister to expand the definition of a ‘mental health professional’ to include psychotherapists, counsellors and psychoanalysts.

The current definition of ‘mental health professional’ is restricted to clinical psychiatrists and professionals holding a postgraduate degree in Ayurveda, homoeopathy, Siddha and Unani—all on the clinical side. Although including specialists from non-allopathic fields of medicine is laudable, it is unclear why psychotherapists and psychoanalysts were excluded.

The minister in charge said on the floor of the House that the expansion of the definition would be taken up, but the draft rules and regulations failed to address this.

Second, the Act proposes an ‘advance medical directive’ through which individuals can dictate how they “wish to be” and “wish not to be treated” and can nominate a member who can make decisions on their behalf should they lose their mental capacity. But it is unable to provide a clear procedure for preparing it.

The original Bill of 2013 outlined how and when a person could create an advance directive, including ascertaining mental insolvency through a standardized process before the application of the directive, and subject to approval by a competent authority. These clauses have been deleted from the Act and do not find mention in the rules. The Act fails to provide for the full list of treatment options available, so that a decision can be taken by the individual without information asymmetry.

Third, the Act provides for the constitution of an expert committee for periodic review and effective implementation of the Act. Neither the Act nor the rules define the constitution, procedure and terms of reference of the committee. Such an important body should be more transparent and subject to public scrutiny.

The Mental Healthcare Act, 2017 is an important legislation that is indicative of a progressive nation. The ministry must listen to stakeholders who have submitted responses on the draft rules and regulations before finalization.

The legislation will be effective only if the gaps pointed out by the stakeholders are discussed and solved. Tardy implementation will cause more harm than good.

 

Source : Live Mint

Join other Aspirants

Enter your Mail ID and get Access for Everything !

SHARE AND SUPPORT
Twitter Facebook Telegram WhatsApp

Related posts:

  1. Fighting the bots for jobs
  2. ASEAN rising — on India-Southeast Asia cooperation
  3. Budget 2018 strikes a reasonable balance
  4. The impact of Alauddin Khilji [History]

Filed Under: Fine Editorials, UPSC Tagged With: Editorials

Comments

  1. Amarendra says

    April 4, 2018 at 10:30 pm

    The article is bit missleading…

    Please find the Right one here

    https://www.livemint.com/Opinion/BdVVXjyKWDhAAcU1ulHwSI/Mental-Healthcare-Act-A-paradigm-shift.html

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Short Notes IAS Yearly Current Affairs Revision  

Recent Posts

  • Rau’s IAS Prelims 2021 Test 20 PDF
  • GS Score Prelims 2021 Test 28 PDF
  • Rau’s IAS Prelims 2021 Test 19 PDF
  • GS Score Prelims 2021 Test 27 PDF
  • GS Score Prelims 2021 Test 26 PDF

Top Posts & Pages

  • UPSC Prelims Test Series
  • Prelims 2021 Test Series
  • Rau's IAS Prelims 2021 Test 20 PDF
  • Indian Economy by Ramesh Singh 12th Edition PDF
  • Standard Books
  • A Brief History of Modern India by Rajiv Ahir (Spectrum) New Edition PDF
  • International Relations by Pavneet Singh PDF
  • GS Score Prelims 2021 Test 28 PDF
  • Sriram IAS Indian Economy 2020 PDF [Latest Edition]
  • Insight IAS Prelims 2021 Test 17 PDF [Subject Wise]

Categories

  • Anthropology Optional (4)
  • ART & CULTURE (11)
  • Coaching Institute Materials (198)
  • Current Affairs (1,057)
  • CURRENT AFFAIRS MONTHLY MAGAZINES (950)
  • DOWNLOAD STANDARD EBOOKS (61)
  • ECONOMICS OPTIONAL (140)
  • ECONOMY (144)
  • ENVIRONMENT & ECOLOGY (10)
  • ESSAY (52)
  • Ethics (4)
  • GEOGRAPHY (9)
  • GEOGRAPHY OPTIONAL (14)
  • Governance (1)
  • GS-1 (29)
  • GS-2 (25)
  • GS-3 (27)
  • GS-4 (30)
  • Hindi Medium (78)
  • Hindi Medium Test Series (80)
  • HISTORY (22)
  • HISTORY OPTIONAL (22)
  • IGNOU (8)
  • Important Articles (14)
  • Important News (82)
  • INTERVIEWS (6)
  • MAINS (10)
  • Mains 2016 Test Series (10)
  • Mains 2018 Test Series (248)
  • Mains 2019 Test Series (285)
  • Mains 2020 Test Series (192)
  • Mains 2021 Test Series (10)
  • Mains Special (44)
  • Mains Test Series (25)
  • MATHEMATICS OPTIONAL (12)
  • Motivation (1)
  • Motivation Mitra (5)
  • NIOS (1)
  • Notifications (34)
  • Optional 2017 Test Series (10)
  • Optional 2018 Test Series (86)
  • Optional 2019 Test Series (88)
  • Optional 2020 Test Series (15)
  • Optional Materials (1)
  • Optional Test Series (122)
  • Other Articles (2)
  • PHILOSOPHY OPTIONAL (3)
  • POLITICAL SCIENCE OPTIONAL (20)
  • POLITY (6)
  • Prelims 2016 Test Series (8)
  • Prelims 2017 Test Series (39)
  • Prelims 2018 Test Series (344)
  • Prelims 2019 Test Series (388)
  • Prelims 2020 Test Series (671)
  • Prelims 2021 Test Series (124)
  • PRELIMS PAPER – 2 (CSAT) (10)
  • PRELIMS PAPER – I (GS) (65)
  • PRELIMS PREVIOUS PAPERS (5)
  • Prelims Special (30)
  • Previous Question Papers (96)
  • Psychology Optional (4)
  • Results (13)
  • Society (1)
  • SOCIOLOGY OPTIONAL (24)
  • Success Mantra (10)
  • TMH (5)
  • Topper Notes (17)
  • Uncategorized (14)
  • UPSC (3,719)

Archives

March 2021
M T W T F S S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031  
« Feb    

Tags

2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 Current Affairs ECONOMICS OPTIONAL ECONOMY Forum IAS Forum IAS Prelims 2020 Test Series GS Score HINDI MEDIUM Hindi Medium Prelims 2019 Test Series Hindi Medium Test Series IAS Baba IAS Baba Prelims 2019 Test Series Insight IAS Insight IAS Current Affairs Insight IAS Prelims 2019 Test Series Insight IAS Prelims 2020 Test Series MAINS Mains 2019 Test Series Mains 2020 Test Series Mains Test Series Mrunal No Ads Optional 2018 Test Series Optional 2019 Test Series Optional Test Series pdf Prelims 2019 Test Series Prelims 2020 Test Series Prelims 2021 Test Series Prelims Test Series Raus IAS Shankar IAS Test Series Unacademy Vajiram Vajiram and Ravi VISION Vision 365 Vision IAS 365 Vision IAS Mains 2020 Test Series VSN IAS

Get Everything in your Inbox

Enter your Mail ID and get Access for Everything !

Copyright © 2021 · About Us · Privacy Policy · Contact Us

We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies.
Cookie settingsACCEPT
Manage consent

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled

Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

Non-necessary

Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.

SAVE & ACCEPT